Metroid: Other M
3 out of 5. You’ve already heard about its problems, but there are some of positives to enjoy, making it a fun game. In an alternate universe this could have been a perfect Metroid game.
Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
3.5 out of 5. While there are some standout scenes, the Metroid identity is somewhat lost in Metroid Prime 3’s more linear focus. The motion controls are novel – when they work correctly.
Metroid Prime 2: Echoes
4.5 out of 5. Metroid Prime 2’s focus on exploration and atmosphere demonstrates spectacularly the high potential for the 3D Metroidvania. While not perfect, it’s a standout in gaming history.
Metroid Prime
3.5 out of 5. As the series’ first foray into the 3D environment, Retro Studios nailed the feel and style of the series while also adapting popular-for-the-time action adventure game puzzles.
La-Mulana
5 out of 5. Not a game for everyone, but perhaps the best puzzle-based Metroidvania in the genre. Cryptic clues and dangerous tombs captures the feel of an Indiana Jones-style archeology adventure.
Cave Story
5 out of 5. While relatively linear and more story focused, Cave Story provides some of the best challenging shooter-platformer gameplay available. Full of secrets to uncover and lovable characters.