3.5 out of 5. Filled to the brim with creativity even with all of its many references to 80s game culture. The punishing difficulty will cut you down to the bone, but if that's your jam, it's amazing.
Share

How Metroidvania is it? Medium Fit. Castle in the Darkness is technically linear with side-paths accessible by a couple of specific abilities. There’s still a Metroidvania “Feel” later on, but it takes a while to get to that point.
Primary Challenge: Melee Combat
Time to beat: ~8 hours
Review Info: Castle in the Darkness was played on Steam

More Info

Developer: Matt Kap
Publisher: Nicalis
Sub-genre: Linear Platformer Hybrid
Features: Map System, 2D Platformer, Melee Combat, Tricky Platforming, Fast Travel/Teleporters, Sequence Breaking
Difficulty: Brutal
Linearity/Openness: High Gating - No Handholding
Platforms: Windows, Steam
Release Date: 2015/02/05
Available Languages: English

Store Links

    Steam    Humble Bundle    

Buy Castle in the Darkness if you like…

  • I Wanna Be the Guy
  • Clever and creative bosses and level design
  • References to 80s pop culture, and video game culture in general
  • Hunting for Obscure Secrets
  • Instant Death Mechanics

▼ Review continues below ▼

Castle in the Darkness is a game you’ll either love or hate, or if you’re like me, both. It’s a creative love letter to pop culture recognizable to anyone born in the United States of America in the 1980s, with an original spin keeping it fresh and curious for nostalgic fans of that era. Part of that love letter was written in blood gathered from the fingers of children after they broke their controllers, however, as all of the punishing difficulty of those ancient games is fully celebrated here. Whether or not this is a deal breaker or an attractive feature just depends on how you like your difficulty served up.

The plot is one anyone familiar with 80s gaming has already heard. An evil Sorcerer is being evil, and the princess is missing. You’re the last surviving of the King’s Guard, and your job is to poke things with your wholly inadequate sword until you find better tools. There are so many direct references to older video games that I dare say that it may be more challenging to list everything that isn’t a reference. You’ll run into good ol’ Firebrand and Arthur from Ghosts ‘n’ Goblins, Blue Hedgehogs, an Elf Boy who tells you it’s dangerous to go alone, Fairies that shout at you to listen, and more. In the midst of all of this though, Castle in the Darkness manages to remain fairly unique in all of its offerings. Bosses may include references to Double Dragon and Symphony of the Night, but the challenges themselves present a fresh take even for those who have played all of those games.

The game even plays on your expectations with some hilarious results – if you don’t mind being kicked in the ribs a few times. For instance, when you reach the titular Castle you’ll find the same kind of candelabras you might find in a Castlevania game, which if you’ve played those games you’re already hardwired to break them as soon as you see them. In Castle in the Darkness however instead of ignoring all logic and offering hearts as a reward for destroying them, the candle instead explodes into a dangerous flame that will likely burn your face if you’re too close.

Bosses are easily the best part of Castle in the Darkness for me, and are the part of the game that justifies the Metroidvania aspect. All of them are excruciatingly difficult if you’re still stuck with the original starting weapon – maybe even impossible in some cases. Every boss defeated gives you a little extra health, and there are other weapons obscured in a very “Zelda 1”-like fashion, meaning that if you’re ever having trouble, finding new tools and switching up your strategy can usually pull you through. A boss that seems unfair will often bow down instantly to the right weapon or spell. It’s fun and rewarding to explore more and take these jerks down.

However, no amount of exploration and secret hunting will help you against your true enemy, Instant Death, and by the end of the game there’s so much of it. I’ve had to take a few days after completing this game to reconcile my personal biases against what is actually counterproductive game design, and I think it really boils down to what you consider to be fair and unfair. If “Fair” to you is a game that is consistent – no RNG – that can be completed with your skill even if it takes a few tries to get foreknowledge of what’s coming, then Castle in the Darkness is a fair game and you may like its antics. If fairness also includes reasonable telegraphing so that an experienced player could reasonably avoid all obstacles without dying, then this game is likely going to rub you the wrong way. I don’t personally have a problem with trial and error mechanics – I think memorization is a skill that’s worth developing and can even be fun to develop. In fact, there are a lot of games that have been successfully based around this concept, like Bit Trip Runner. I personally think Castle in the Darkness crosses the line a little too far – and this is coming from someone who would adamantly defend Quick Man’s stage in Mega Man 2 as a good level. There are too many death traps that come from off screen at speed that it’s impossible for you to react fast enough. It’s incredibly frustrating to have defeated a hard boss only to slip slightly and die instantly on a spike as you return to the nearest save point. “Gotcha” moments can be funny, but they get old pretty quick when you’re really just here for the game’s other offerings. Unfortunately as the game progresses it starts to look closer to a game like I Wanna Be the Guy than it does something like Metroid or Castlevania – which again is a great thing if that’s your jam.

To be fair though, the worst of the game’s frustrations are technically optional, and it’s not all bad even when instant death is involved. I really enjoyed the prison section of the game where navigating instant death corridors are practically the main theme. I also think that all of the game’s existing challenges are serviceable – it just perhaps needs a few more checkpoints to even out the wonky difficulty curve.

There’s a lot of talent that went into Castle in the Darkness, and if you are able to enjoy the punishing difficulty, you’ll find a rich world filled with secrets and challenges. You may even consider it one of your top games. I personally respect the unbridled design; the unburdened expression of the game’s creator. Castle in the Darkness made me smile more than it made me bleed, but you’ll have to excuse me while I get some more band-aids.


Final Score

3.5/5

Scoring system overview


Metroidvania Breakdown

Combat
– 4

Combat is basic, but there are a varety of weapons and spells that you can use to change up your strategy, adding depth to preparation

Platforming
– 3.5

Technically excellent at points, but the constant barrage of instant death mechanics will likely chip away at your sanitiy

Exploration
– 3.5

Secrets are tucked away behind hidden walls and riddles, but it's done with little guidance. Reminiscent of the first Zelda game

Puzzle
– 3

Not a huge focus, but there are some good riddles to help you figure out some of the more difficult secrets

Story
– 3

The narrative does its job. Nothing special but doesn't detract from the game either

Graphics
– 4

Ranges from a generic 8-bit look to some gorgeous pixel art portraits. Overall high quality

Music
– 4.5

Intentionally uses musical phrases from nostalgic games, and its as good as its inspirations because of that

Replayability
– 3

If you aren't completely beaten down from your first playthrough there's a new game + mode with even more secrets to unlock


Want a second opinion? See what other reviews say:

Steam Reviews
All Time: Mostly Positive
(78% of 1,043 Reviews)


76 Metacritic
Read critic reviews